diff --git a/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/gfx/Image.bf b/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/gfx/Image.bf
index 48b84d7a..8d15f1ef 100644
--- a/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/gfx/Image.bf
+++ b/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/gfx/Image.bf
@@ -18,7 +18,8 @@ namespace Beefy.gfx
 			None = 0,
 			Additive = 1,
 			NoPremult = 2,
-			AllowRead = 4
+			AllowRead = 4,
+			FatalError = 8
 		}
 
         public Image mSrcTexture;
@@ -99,7 +100,11 @@ namespace Beefy.gfx
 
             void* aNativeTextureSegment = Gfx_LoadTexture(fileName, (int32)flags);
             if (aNativeTextureSegment == null)
-                return null;
+            {
+				if (flags.HasFlag(.FatalError))
+					Internal.FatalError(scope $"Failed to load image '{fileName}'");
+				return null;
+			}
 
             return CreateFromNativeTextureSegment(aNativeTextureSegment);
         }
diff --git a/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/theme/dark/DarkTheme.bf b/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/theme/dark/DarkTheme.bf
index eb56ec8e..98e59f1a 100644
--- a/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/theme/dark/DarkTheme.bf
+++ b/BeefLibs/Beefy2D/src/theme/dark/DarkTheme.bf
@@ -308,7 +308,7 @@ namespace Beefy.theme.dark
 			if (sSrcImgScale > 1)
 				fileName.AppendF("_{0}", sSrcImgScale);
 			fileName.Append(".png");
-			var image = Image.LoadFromFile(fileName);
+			var image = Image.LoadFromFile(fileName, .FatalError);
 			image.Scale(GS!(48) / image.mWidth);
 			return image;
 		}
@@ -372,7 +372,7 @@ namespace Beefy.theme.dark
 
 			mIconError = LoadSizedImage("IconError");
 			mIconWarning = LoadSizedImage("IconWarning");
-			mThemeImage = Image.LoadFromFile(fileName);
+			mThemeImage = Image.LoadFromFile(fileName, .FatalError);
 			if (mThemeImage == null)
 			{
 				// Fail (just crashes now)